Kommentare zu: From Idgie to Arizona – My Nominees for AfterEllen’s Top 50 Lesbian/Bi Characters Survey

Von: chubby

chubby — Tue, 23 Mar 2010 10:17:40 +0000

Sometimes it seems like Marienhof and Verbotene Liebe are taking turns, and right now, it’s Marienhof’s turn.
———————————————————————————————-
thats´true: 1. andrea/andrea and billi (marienhof) 2. nina /nina und erika/jule (forbidden love) 3.andrea and billi part 2 (marienhof) 4. carla von lahnstein (forbidden love) 5. kerstin und juliette (marienhof)

i think we don´t become a new lesbian charakter so long christian and olli in the show and carla (and stella) have more guest apperance in the future.
stella mann for me was a chance to tell new story after claudia hiersche has leave the show (there was other option for carla to become here happy and in love), but the chief author, from forbidden love bernadette feiler, doesn´t want that. for this was a mistake. gay- and lesbian stories ever be a part of the soap.

Von: MeL

MeL — Sun, 21 Mar 2010 18:03:26 +0000

I hope that they won’t wait too long before bringing a new lesbian character in, especially given the success of Carla von Lahnstein, and also “Chrolli” (= the gay couple Christian and Olli). But who knows. Sometimes it seems like Marienhof and Verbotene Liebe are taking turns, and right now, it’s Marienhof’s turn.

Von: chubby

chubby — Sun, 21 Mar 2010 15:46:16 +0000

Do you believe that espiecelly “forbidden love” become a new lesbian /bi role in the future, mel?

Von: chubby

chubby — Sun, 21 Mar 2010 15:38:10 +0000

Carla deserves every bit of happiness she seems to have finally found with Stella
—————————————————————————————————————
if carla has poblem´s with her family and she wants to be a human were she can be only carla,, everytime she goes in the arms of the wife she love. carla is an control-freak like bette porter, but this is what we can see by hanna, susanne and stella. this was like a red thread running through the story of carla von lahnstein. and there she found love, stability and strengh.and this is luck for me.

Von: chubby

chubby — Sun, 21 Mar 2010 15:01:36 +0000

it is so great for me and a respekt for claudia hiersche that SHE in the international! list. that says all for me.
“carla von lahnstein” was a great popular role, play by the amazing claudia hiersche.
it is an honor, she is in the list, at the point claudia hiersche leave “forbidden love”, because, she wants to play other things. 6 jears “carla” it was a great time.and this is like the “main point.”

my list:
1. carla von lahnstein
2. susanne brandner
3. bette porter
4. tina kennard
5. billi voigt
6. alice pieszecki
7. dana fairbanks
8. dr. kerry weaver
9. dra. maca fernández wilson
10. esther garcia

Von: MeL

MeL — Sat, 13 Mar 2010 20:47:23 +0000

The final spot on my list eventually went to Tanja Schildknecht of the German TV show Lindenstraße, mainly because she has been a lesbian for over a decade now. For a while, I also considered Kerry Weaver of ER. If I remember correctly, AE intends to publish the list on Monday. Can’t wait to see who made the list.

Von: Jerri

Jerri — Wed, 10 Mar 2010 11:18:23 +0000

Hhhm, interesting lists. I would definitely have to have Carla and Stella at the top, and but then, its an open field.

1. Carla Lahnstein
2. Stella Mann
3. Olivia Spencer
4. Natalia Riviera
5. Nikki Wade
6. Helen Stewart
7. Xena
8. Gabrielle
9. Tara
10. Willow

Von: harper

harper — Wed, 10 Mar 2010 00:47:20 +0000

emily fitch. that’s all i have to say.

Von: MeL

MeL — Fri, 26 Feb 2010 19:06:17 +0000

Thanks @all for your suggestions and @JM for sharing your list of nominees. Reading all those names of great lesbian / bi characters makes me somewhat optimistic that we aren’t as invisible as we might think we are after all. And it’s getting better and better.

As for my 10th nominee, so far I’m considering Tanja Schildknecht (German TV show Lindenstraße) and Luce (Imagine Me and You). But please, keep the suggestions coming!

Von: JM

JM — Fri, 26 Feb 2010 17:31:09 +0000

How about Luce from Imagine Me and You? Or Dr. Kim Legaspi from ER? Why not Peggy Peabody? Spashley?

As for my nominees, here they are in no particular order.
1. Idgie Threadgoode
2. Bette Porter
3. Nikki Wade
4. Carla von Lahnstein
5. Dr. Maggie Doyle
6. Dr. Erica Hahn
7. Simone Bradley
8. Luce
9. Dana Fairbanks
10. Ellen Morgan